35 Comments

Yes. We should also be talking about how gun violence is impacting kids trying to go to school. A quick scan of the news shows countless schools closed on any given day for mourning following shootings or because there have been posted threats to the schools. Some of these closures go on for days. This should outrage anyone who claims to care about the nation’s children getting reliable in-person education.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Ruth, for focusing on this topic. I, for one, am very close to losing hope about this issue. Not only are we not making laws to make it more difficult to get/carry firearms, the laws are going the other way! This country is an embarrassment. Every developed country in the world thinks we're nuts to allow private citizens to carry weapons. They're right. If our founding fathers knew what was going on, they would tell us "Hey, Congress, can't you read?? We said 'A well-regulated militia...' for a reason. That's why we made those the FIRST FOUR WORDS of the Second Amendment".

Expand full comment
May 9, 2023Liked by Ruth Ben-Ghiat

I heard of something in the UK called The Paupers Union or The Debtors Union. The Idea is that low income people could pool their collective purchasing power by steering their shopping habits away for anti labor businesses. I really liked the idea as well as the distinctly British humorous juxtaposition of concepts =] Im wondering if something like that might get US corporations attention. They probably would not be so keen on its customers developing the habit of making their own lattes or hitting up thrift stores on weekends instead of the mall! Great post Professor, as always =]

Expand full comment
May 9, 2023Liked by Ruth Ben-Ghiat

As pitiful as it is to realize, we MUST get the money out of our politics - away from our greedy politicians. If that can’t happen, then we get new politicians who will accept the gun violence insanity MUST STOP.

Expand full comment
May 9, 2023Liked by Ruth Ben-Ghiat

Great article Ruth, I had not thought of the economic/business angle towards gaining meaningful traction on gun control …..the current mass shooting epidemic is staggering !

Expand full comment

American businesses could also do the obvious - stop funding Republican politicians.

Expand full comment

It's tragic to think that this argument, rather than the loss of lives, specifically children (over and over again) will likely have better outcomes on the national stage. Sickening, but ...always about the money.

Expand full comment

Unfortunately the inertia in the status quo over gun violence in America is because it has become "normalized" as a part of life in this country. And that is an unmitigated tragedy. I suppose the costs to businesses for security are seen as just another expense like paying for health insurance for its employees?

Mass shootings and carnage have become inbedded into the psyche of the country. Authoritarians and MAGA like it because it prepares the country to accept the use of gun violence as a means of achieving political goals.

"Thoughts and prayers" is a typical response from NRA politicians like Ted Cruz. We have to understand that no change will occur no matter how high the body count unless extremest Republican politicians like him are voted out of office and replaced with Democrats who will vote to pass meaningful gun legislation that includes assault rifle bans.

Expand full comment

Yes. 100%!

When we see the aftermath of a mass shooting, notice the response? Easily more than 100, maybe 1,000 police ( city, county, state, FBI, EMS, SWAT, counselors, etc)...It is as if entire cities and counties rush all their resources: officers, vehicles, and equipment to the school, mall, synagogue, church, etc. What does the response cost us tax payers in dollars? Shouldn't that be part of the economic equation? And then what is the cost of the associated collective trauma of the shooting to the communities and public servants where they occur? How could one even measure that?

Expand full comment
May 9, 2023·edited May 9, 2023

Thank you for another timely piece.

Not an argument that I personally need to hear, but excellent fodder to use when making arguments to those apparently otherwise unmoved. And an excellent demonstration of how we’ll need to find new arguments/avenues if we are going to get anywhere on this issue - the current situation is only worsening.

Expand full comment

Elected Republican politicians are either out of touch, or just plain ignoring the desires of their constituents. A majority of both Democrats and Republicans want assault weapons banned, but that desire is falling on deaf Republican ears. In 2024 (even starting right now), it needs to be made crystal clear that if the voters want common sense gun laws, the only way to make that happen is to vote out their Republican representatives. Shout it loud, and often.

Expand full comment

An idea - not automatically using the word ‘elites’ to describe Republican fascist wannabes or the 1% or members of Congress. None of those categories fit the real definition of ‘elite’.

Expand full comment

The people needing to ‘ hear’ this aren’t the targeted ones, nor are ‘their’ children, nor is ‘their ‘ pocketbook. The ‘theirs’ are the ones promoting the violence, taking the contributions from dark sources , pointing the fingers at our President, our policies, our solutions. They’re holding the American people in hostage , the people who 80%+ want the gun control, want the education/teachers/curriculum better, who now have doubts or trust the establishment because the establishment is corrupt. Not the whole mind you but the ones who talk the trash, implement the restrictions/gerrymander, take away our free choices under the false flags of righteousness, the ones who still think TFG won,and can’t see the slow methodical lies.

It’s an insidiously controlled bandwagon .

💙VOTE💙

Expand full comment

I forget too often to say thanks , Ruth. To all of you whose comments , writs, and efforts pave the way to winning . 2024 looms ever more quickly. It is an always battle against the oppressors, so stay the course compadres. We need every one of you.❤️

Expand full comment

Economic impact. Gun industry is 80 billion a year in this country, with 19 billion profit in 2020. The industry is worth aprox 28 billion, as a whole. Lobbying spent 9.5 million in 2022. The industry employs 169,523, not including families. 16 million firearms were sold in 2022, alone. 45% of American households own at least one firearm. There are 81 million gun owners in this country. There are 434 million guns, along with a staggering amount of ammunition. 42 Senators and numerous in the House are rated as “C” or better with the NRA. I quit counting all the “Christian” Senators who take gun lobby money, but Ted Cruz doesn’t hold the record. The record actually goes to family man extraordinaire and Jesus loving Christian, Mitt Romney, at 13 million dollars.

1. End Citizens United.

2. Outlaw lobbying.

3. Bring back the Brady bill as a minimum.

4. Work local/state legislation.

5. End limits to firearm lawsuits and loopholes.

After we do all this, we can figure out how to get the 434 million guns off the street, as well as how to reclaim the buried ammunition. It would be easier to resurrect and elect Ross Perot as President. I don’t see any mass protests. I don’t see any boycotting. I don’t see a mass movement to demand divestment in 401k. I don’t see any of the 169,523 workers quitting.

I see liars, Christian political leaders and their lies. We have become a nation of baby killers. We sit in disgust at what people like Epstein did to children, while our nation murders them. Just so you know ahead of time, I will not answer any ignorant or hateful comments. We are hypocrites, in our comfort zone, as our children and all citizens die. We will reap what we sow.

Expand full comment

Thank you Professor Ruth for a look at the financial prism. Another interesting view, would be to take the $557B cost to the national economy and divide that by the 50 states, coming up with a cost, or in republicans' terms a 'tax' if you will, of $11B+ to each state's economy. This semantical view goes against republican policy of lowered taxes. States cannot afford this burden, and to some states this 'cost' is devastating to their balance sheets. We are in essence, defunding the states

Expand full comment