113 Comments
User's avatar
james l gardner's avatar

Great article we have to Stand up see something say something

Expand full comment
Linda Weide's avatar

I think it is clear what it will take for people to notice, particularly those who have voted for Trump. Instead of just waiting for the Red States governments and folks to wake up, Robert Hubbell has been suggesting not just a general strike, but also a tax strike, what do you think of that latter? Not funding the government at least in Blue states, could be harmful to the Musk/Trump agenda. What could they do to go after millions of people refusing to pay taxes when they are getting rid of everyone who knows how to collect them?

Expand full comment
Lesley H.'s avatar

there is an economic blackout planned for Feb 28th!!! No spending of any kind except cash at locally owned businesses!!!

also, I have been thinking of the taxes as well for a couple of reasons,

1) no matter what blue states might do to appease Trump, nothing will work as we have seen already. he's vindictive so there is no point in trying to appease. the punishment will come. and,

2) the blue states will need money as fed funding is cut off. to maintain our quality of life, our programs, the very things that make us successful enough to fund the bloody government in the first place need to be preserved or we too will fall victim to the southern economic "development" strategy. I have been thinking of sending my IRS taxes to the state instead. But I think the blue states should take this idea and ask the residents to do this, not just me doing it on my own.

We need protection from the IRS for this - ie, to do it collectively. The IRS would have to audit 100’s of 1000’s of blue state residents and well.. do they have enough people for this? I mean, how *is* the IRS going to continue to function without people?

And if I were an IRS auditor, I not feel disgusting chasing down 85 yr old pensioners for $15K + interest knowing the first thing Trump ordered tax wise was an end to the audits worth $800M on the tax evasion by his cronies?! How would an IRS agent feel at all ethical chasing down middle class people for taxes while ignoring the cabal of the 1%ers?

Lastly, I do not believe the election - this last one - nor any coming will be real. I’m sorry, but this last one didn’t pass the smell test, and we know they did not count something like over 2M ballots - mail ins, drop box, “late” registrations, provisional ballots, and 100,000’s of “signature mismatches” according to new “handwriting experts” counting ballots. A black voter was 400x more likely to have their ballot uncounted - strange how that is isn’t it for a perfectly valid election? ANYWAY, when we do overthrow this regime- which we will at some point, Im thinking people who chose not to give their money to a criminal cabal via their taxes are not going to be punished.

One thing I do know is that I don’t want to go back. I would not choose to roll this regime back to have Kamela take over what was a completely filthy and broken government, just to maintain the status quo. The dems I finally accepted after the election were a Vichy party all along. I never believed it until December. I felt so, so betrayed. I cried. I raged. And then I accepted it.

So, as a lot of experts in history have suggested, we should focus on our local communities, and for those of us in blue states, our state is a community and our government has actually put in policies that helped us, and in fact were what “Made America Great” at all. We should give them our taxes, not this government.

Expand full comment
Ruth Joachim's avatar

Beautifully written as always. Ruth: what do you see as the role of former American leaders, and their spouses given the terrible turn of events? Yes, I mean Presidents, but other leaders — political, military, economic, etc. f

Five former Treasury secretaries wrote an op ed in the NYT. But there is surely more to be done by leaders no longer bound by elections or appointments. Are they scared? Waiting for a more opportune time? Why aren’t we hearing outrage?

Expand full comment
Debra Boyle's avatar

I have this same question. I would like to hear from Democrats but also particularly from former Republican leaders -- George W. Bush, his brother Jeb, Mitt Romney, Paul Ryan, etc. They could join Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger and get loud. It upsets me that they, like the Congressional Republicans, media, Wall Street, and corporate leaders are cowering in front of Trump's threats, trying to fly under the radar. I hope I have the courage my uncle and family friends had on D-Day and my other family members had both in WWII and later wars and at home to stand up and save democracy. I believe there are many of us who will. It would help to see some of our so-called "leaders" step up as well.

Expand full comment
Michael G Baer's avatar

Debra, thank you for saying this and for your courage. I wonder about all the millions of military, past and present, who swore an oath to defend the Constitition against ALL enemies, foreign and domestic. They have risked their lives overseas to a much greater extent than they would be risking their lives by speaking up and acting up now. Its hard to believe the military is silent in these critical days in the existential threat of our democratic republic.

Expand full comment
Linda Weide's avatar

GW Bush is pretty close to a Trumper with his policies, and isn't he a Christian Nationalist? They are all so racist and misogynist they cannot get beyond themselves. They are supporting screwing the planet their grandchildren inherit.

Expand full comment
Sherri's avatar

GWB has stayed in his corner less one moment when he supported Collins for Senate and state funerals. Romney has made it carefully clear to me and he's obviously scared and Rand Paul ... yuck ... he remains the same to me. Jeb just seems scared.

I don't know about a cowering WS. I haven't seen it and murdoch's WSJ (which I loathe) is still being delivered to people around my neighborhood (and my bro-in-law who worked for Price Waterhouse Cooper as a corp lawyer still reads the paper and enjoys it and hates Mump).

It would help if magas stepped up and no one else, in my opinion. The lie has taken the oxygen out of life. orban and putin and other autocracies have taught his real handlers well - make gaza into a resort make me want to throw up on a large red tie.

Expand full comment
Ruth Joachim's avatar

Thank you! We need answers! I’m currently on an Airlift call where Robert Hubble is a guest. Airlift is joining with Movement Voters Project (MVP). Does anyone have more information about Feb 17 protest?

Expand full comment
Ted's avatar

None. Need more 411.

Expand full comment
ANNE's avatar

I keep wondering why we are not hearing more from Barack Obama. I believe he decided to lay low during the first Trump administration, thinking he would be a convenient distraction for them if he got too vocal, but there is nothing to lose at this point. He could get on any news show he wanted, and would make news with his comments. He is good at explaining things. Where is he???

Expand full comment
Lesley H.'s avatar

im sorry, but the Dems were a Vichy gov't. They helped pave the way for this because they have been complicit all along. There has been no way to run for office in the US without millions and millions of dollars. To get and keep a career in politics you had to take money from donors where you got them, and if you look at the record, most dems took money from the same people republicans did. Russian oligarchs included.

Expand full comment
Ruth Joachim's avatar

Go to Indivisible.org and enter your zip code for places you can go on Feb 17 (Monday) to peacefully protest. State Capitol. City Hall. You name it.

Expand full comment
David Holzman's avatar

EDIT Note: Indivisible.com is not not the same thing as Indivisible.org. Our Indivisible is Indivisible.org. Indivisible.com is a commercial firm for investing in securities.

Expand full comment
Lesley H.'s avatar

peaceful protesting will put pressure on local governments but nothing else. I suggest a targeted strategy- ie, something specific we want the state gov't to do. It's important to know that Republicans are cowering because it's so dangerous for them to refuse to follow the regime. they really can't unless they can reach a critical mass to refuse the lawlessness and they have been bought so long ago its really never going to happen. they are 100% owned. as are most of the Dems.

This is why I think we should be asking our blue states to protect us from the daily fresh hell unleashed on the govt that directly effect Blue states, ie, the infrastructure bill funding that has been frozen. the Medicaid, medicare, SS, and VA benefits about to be severely cut for more trillion dollar tax breaks for billionaires. the blue states need to replace the money they are losing if they want to keep their programs in place. we should ask them to 1) not give any more money to the fed govt, ie, taxes, etc. and 2) lead us, their residents, in a mass action to pay our fed taxes to our states instead. they need the money, we need the programs. the money has to come from somewhere.

Expand full comment
Ruth Joachim's avatar

I am SO sorry. You are absolutely right David!! I just edited my previous post.

Expand full comment
David Holzman's avatar

Thank you Ruth.

Expand full comment
Linda Weide's avatar

AOC is not given the leadership she should be getting from the Democratic party, but she is speaking truth to power. She has dealt with Bully White Boys all her life, and recognizes who they are, what they do that appeals to people and what to point out to their voters to get them to connect to the actions of Trump and Musk to their own harm.

Expand full comment
David Holzman's avatar

We should definitely tell her she's doing a great job and that she deserves more power in the Democratic party!

Expand full comment
Linda Weide's avatar

Change probably to definitely and I will whole heartedly agree. We should also be writing to the new chair and co-chair of the DNC and tell them we want to see her given more leadership her own way.

Expand full comment
David Holzman's avatar

Thanks. Done!

Expand full comment
Stephen Pardys's avatar

The Democrats and any citizens who wish to help need to rapidly build a levee before there is a Noah.s flood that washes away our republic. Bertrand Russell stated it very succinctly when he wrote on how Fascism starts: first they fascinate the fools, then they muzzle the intelligent.

Expand full comment
Juliana Paré-Blagoev's avatar

I’m also worried about how colleges and universities decided to muzzle themselves by supporting Institutional neutrality and institutional restraint. In doing so, they have also given up fighting for institutional autonomy.

This is the start up of a Mao style cultural revolution.

Expand full comment
Lesley H.'s avatar

yeah, I really can't understand why they have done anything the fed as asked. everyone fails to understand that appeasement isn't going to work. the policy is set, and shutting down the experts and the intelligent as Russell states is a requirement for a regime to be secured. no matter what institutions (news organizations, etc etc) do to bow down it's not going to make a difference, as they are finding out.

Expand full comment
Friedrike Merck's avatar

You are one brilliant woman, and one great American. You are a true anchor in this storm. Thank you for your dedication to the cause, thank you.

Expand full comment
Susan Cortilet Jones (link ⬇️)'s avatar

Ruth- I laid in bed this afternoon after walking dogs, house cleaning, walking dogs some more and turned on Deadline WH (Nicole Wallace) to the news of Kath Patel (traitor) and Elon Musk, his son, and Trump at the sacred resolute desk. In the title of his book Rick Wilson, "Everything Trump Touches Dies".

Expand full comment
Debra Boyle's avatar

Thank you for this.

Expand full comment
Kelly Eggers's avatar

OMG Ruth. What a horrifying picture you paint. Thank you thank you for your bravery in teaching us what is happening and what it means for everyone. We hang on your every word. We are with you and will resist. Bless you. Stay safe and strong.♥️

Expand full comment
Susan Cortilet Jones (link ⬇️)'s avatar

I will protest on the 17th, called my representatives today and will attend a town hall with Valerie Foushee tomorrow night online. What is increasingly concerning me, is the people I follow are like that giant puzzle we use to give as gifts at Christmas. We turn the box over with all the pieces (Youtube, BlueSky, Substack, Instagram, TikTok, MSM) and all the smaller pieces that will take me, at least, years to complete. Everyone is asking for money. USAID is bankrupt, because of Trump. The VP or President, Elon Musk is targeting agencies that provide valuable and life saving services to constituents. And then there are the agencies (Red Cross, HAIS and others) asking for money to support their emergency efforts. This puzzle is so scattered that we, Americans, are a mirror image of the disjointedness of an uncompleted puzzle sitting on our table. What do we do? Where do we start? I follow the declining gorilla population in the Congo and the wars that are increasingly threatening these populations. What do we do? Where do we start?

Expand full comment
David J. Sharp's avatar

A coming moral reckoning? Optimistic … but I doubt it. In the Fifties, when those who (quietly) protested were called “eggheads,” and they were mocked; today those who protest are not just mocked but threatened. And we all see before us, in Congress where the people are supposed to have a voice, the lack of spine is everywhere. Daddy is tucking in his baby boys.

Expand full comment
David Barrett's avatar

Mate violence against protestors is nothing new. Ask any black person.

Violence against more mainstream white protestors is returning. And it sucks. But twas ever thus.

Expand full comment
Pamela Tanton's avatar

Living for belief in the reckoning.

Expand full comment
Gene Krzyzynski's avatar

Steven Levitsky, in an article for The Atlantic titled "The New Authoritarianism," writes:

"Democracy is not yet lost. The Trump administration will be politically vulnerable. Unlike successful elected authoritarians such as Nayib Bukele in El Salvador, Hugo Chávez in Venezuela, and Vladimir Putin in Russia, Trump lacks broad popular support. His approval rating has almost never surpassed 50 percent, and incompetence, overreach, and unpopular policies will almost certainly dampen public support for the new administration. An autocratic president with an approval rating below 50 percent is still dangerous, but far less so than one with 80 percent support. The new administration’s political weakness will open up opportunities for opposition in the courtroom, on the streets, and at the ballot box.

"Still, the opposition can win only if it stays in the game. Worn down by defeat, and fearing harassment and lost opportunities, many civic leaders and activists will be tempted to pull back into their private lives. It’s already happening. But a retreat to the sidelines could be fatal for democracy. When fear, exhaustion, or resignation eclipses our commitment to democracy, competitive authoritarianism succeeds."

***

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/02/trump-competitive-authoritarian/681609/

***

(Orange Duce is known for doubling down. Those of us who love democracy must double down, too.)

Expand full comment
Kathy Hughes's avatar

And he has a megalomaniacal billionaire whose special K use is altering his sense of reality.

Expand full comment
Steve Rasmussen's avatar

I believe that most, if not all of those surrounding tRump are sociopaths/psychopaths or have narcissistic personality disorder. These seem to be a prerequisite for fascism, not to mention sadism and Machiavellianism.

Expand full comment
Juliana Paré-Blagoev's avatar

There are three huge factors that make this move into authoritarianism more dangerous than any other in history: the degree of surveillance now possible, the percentage of the population dependent on a vast transportation network for their access to food, and the vast armament held by individual citizens.

Are others finding resources/authors that speak to mitigating these factors?

Expand full comment
Steve Rasmussen's avatar

The courts have been having some success in stifling tRump's agenda, however, enforcing the edicts can be a problem when tRump refuses to comply. The courts can use the US Marshalls Service to enforce their standing but the problem with this is that the Marshalls Service is a part of DOJ and tRump has control of them. tRump has said that he will honor the courts' decisions but I don't trust him at all to honor his word. He has no honor or any other virtue. I believe his disregarding the courts will cause a huge crisis, and will be the tipping point for our democracy. At that point, we will pull this mess out of the fire or go down in flames.

Expand full comment
Lesley H.'s avatar

they aren't actually fully complying anyway. Musk isn't at least. and honestly, they don't have to. there is no way to enforce the courts. state capture has occurred already. and WHY OH WHY do people still think voting is going to make an iota of difference?! jfc that is over. 2024 proved it.

Expand full comment
Michael G Baer's avatar

what about these dudes and dudettes as the enforcers of the law?

https://youtube.com/shorts/wydAs9MgCb4?si=zJTuzxENRCm_1hSx

Expand full comment
Steve Rasmussen's avatar

tRump will try to emasculate these people and render them useless. He may not succeed.

Expand full comment
Leigh Horne's avatar

Best. Article. I've. Seen. On the coming reckoning. It couldn't have been easy to write and it sure wasn't easy to read. But easy isn't the highest value. Thank you, Ruth. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Dianne Hammer's avatar

Agree. Wasn’t easy to read and I feel like throwing up, but I appreciate fully understanding the implications.

Expand full comment
james l gardner's avatar

Thanks

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Fenlon's avatar

New rights for the few and limited or no rights for the many sounds like what is happening now. Everything you say makes perfect sense.

Expand full comment
Deborah Alecson's avatar

Ruth, we have to evolve from the personal obsession of threats to our lives to the collective threat to our lives and I don't know if we have it in us to do so. We are so entrenched in death denial and death anxiety that we are paralyzed.

Expand full comment
Juliana Paré-Blagoev's avatar

Hope comes from action. Action in solidarity with others helps us to move from fearing for our own safety to fighting for the safety of our communities.

Expand full comment
David Holzman's avatar

We need to think about all the people who will depend on us to lead the way, and then we need to do it.

Expand full comment
james l gardner's avatar

Thanks

Expand full comment